(Manfred Klimek)
There are a few, rare recurring moments in the life of a wine tinkerer that quietly bring you to your knees – humility & prostration. Entirely without bells, without a drum roll, without the inflationary cheering thrown at so many trivialities of our age.
Quite simply: you sit there, looking at bottles – and realise that you are witnessing an achievement that really ought not to be possible.
Such a moment is Stefan Steinmetz’s 2024 collection of dry Rieslings.
No other collection of dry Rieslings on the Mosel – indeed, probably in the whole of Germany – possesses this radical breadth, this insane depth, this almost biblical diversity of styles. It is as if someone had passed the entire Mosel through a prism and filled each refraction into its own bottle. And that is without even mentioning the four fruit-sweet wines, Steinmetz’s impressive collection of red-vineyard Pinot Noirs, or his three to four annual experimental wines (more on those next Sunday in WELT am SONNTAG)
Steinmetz is – like Markus Molitor – a winemaker who does not bottle sites, but lays them bare. Exposes them.
But he does not do it calculatingly; he does it with brutally honest directness. Without smoothing out the style, without any arbitrariness.
Every site here is its own document of reality.
All of this with a precisionso absurdly precise that you almost forget that wine is made by people at all.
Let’s begin
1 – Brauneberger Riesling 2024
The house’s most dependable estate Riesling – and in 2024 with a straight-line precision that comes across as almost insultingly assured.
Less stone fruit than usual, but wonderfully clear, damp quince, gooseberry, a hint of kohlrabi, a little bay leaf at the edges, rosehip as a fine lubricating film – and then those famous slate salts like the final full stop in the sip.
11.5% alcohol, 4 g sugar.
2 – Wintricher Riesling 2024
Distinctly creamier than the Brauneberger.
White peach, acacia blossom, along with yellow pepper in a homeopathic dose, poppy flower and an entire meadow full of herbs. More fruit sweetness, more juice, less salt – a Riesling with a broad chest and open arms.
10.5%, 7 g sugar.
3 – Brauneberger Juffer Kabinett (dry) 2024
A Kabinett on the boundary of being bone-dry – and therefore a Kabinett for grown-ups.
Greengage, white peach, a hint of blue plum. Lime and lemongrass like a fresh blade.
9.5% alcohol, 6 g sugar, 9.5 g acidity.
The ideal wine for Asian cuisine – and for people who believe Kabinett cannot be serious.
4 – Drohner Hofberger Gewanne “Kandel” 2024
Abundant volume.
One of the “great” Rieslings in this collection – fat, full of force, with deep, sinewy slate minerality.
Fruit in abundance, herbs almost gone, no vegetables whatsoever – a Riesling that goes with roast without buckling under the strain.
12.5% alcohol, 1 g sugar.
5 – Brauneberger Juffer “GB” 2024
Bready, powerful, full of stone fruit and greengage.
Great spice.
A Riesling with deep breath and a long perspective.
12.5% alcohol, 1.6 g sugar.
The great Brauneberger, and it knows it.
6 – Zeltinger Sonnenuhr “GZ” 2024
More nut, pear, apricot, dark mint, pink grapefruit.
A Riesling like a knife cut: sharp, long, sinewy.
12.5% alcohol, 2.3 g sugar.
7 – Wintricher Geierslay “GW” 2024
Finer, more elegant, more alcoholic – but with the silkiest structure of the entire collection.
Green pepper, wet pebbles, a stream spring – a Riesling distilled from cool morning air.
13% alcohol, 3.4 g sugar.
8 – Wintricher Ohligsberg “GW” 2024
Brotherly related to the Geierslay – but with more substance, more depth, less delicacy.
A light chive note that makes it irresistible as a beef-broth wine.
12.5% alcohol, 3.4 g sugar.
The most food-oriented Steinmetz of 2024.
9 – Drohner Hofberger GG 2024
A monument.
Crystal-clear, elegant, huge, without seeming heavy.
Slate, fruit, mushrooms, hazelnut – everything is there, and nothing pushes forward.
13% alcohol, 1.4 g sugar.
The great “pure-class” Riesling of this year.
10 – Detzemer Klosterlay GG 2024
A stone-fruit monster, but an elegant one.
Raspberry, cherry, citrus, nut – and behind it a store of longevity that is almost impossible to drink through.
12.5% alcohol, 3.6 g sugar.
The long-lived fruit giant.
11 – Drohner Grosser Hengelberg GG 2024
The most feminine Riesling in the collection.
Apricot, fine spontaneous-fermentation rubber, everything floats.
13% alcohol, 4 g sugar.
12 – Neumagener Rosengärtchen “Am Fels” 2024
A monument to elegance.
A single vine, young – and already great.
Almost no citrus notes, hardly any nut, no vegetable nuances – pure slate fruit in monumental tranquillity.
12.5% alcohol, 2.6 g sugar.
The great long-distance wine of the collection.
The négociant wines – for the Bordelais (!)
13 – Piesporter Treppchen GG 2024
Hazelnut, walnut shell, chestnut, black earth, humus – a Riesling from a library of ancient roots.
12.5% alcohol, 4 g sugar.
14 – Neumagener Rosengärtchen GG 2024
Fucking dry.
Elegant stone fruit, lots of wild raspberries, rosehip, broom – an aristocratic Riesling, clear as a bell.
12.5% alcohol, 1 g sugar.
A wine like a samurai cut.
15 – Neumagener Rosengärtchen VdT 2024
Suckling 99 points – entirely deserved.
Total balance: stone fruit, raspberry, slate, elegance.
13% alcohol, 2.3 g sugar.
One of the best Mosel Rieslings of the year. Full stop.
16 – Piesporter Treppchen VdT 2024
Cooler, saltier, more vegetal – and yet full of stone fruit.
A guaranteed 30-year runner.
12.5% alcohol, 1.6 g sugar.
A Riesling with the breath of a cathedral.
17 – Drohner Hofberger Reserve 2024
Kohlrabi, cold spinach, Nashi pear, quartzite, green apple, slight meatiness.
A Riesling that has both body and spirit.
13% alcohol, 2.4 g sugar.
The most powerful, overwhelming Steinmetz Reserve in years.
18 – Drohner Grosser Hengelberg Reserve 2024
The king of the collection.
Stockinger casks.
Fruit in the finest elegance.
50 years’ ageing potential.
13% alcohol, 2.6 g sugar.
The Riesling that will still be discussed in 2075.
Steinmetz 2024 is not a vintage – it is an encyclopaedia.
There are winemakers who are good every year.
There are a few winemakers who are great in some years.
And then there is Steinmetz – who with 2024 presents a dry collection that simply ought not to be possible.
Yes, he can!
