WinepartyThe Wineparty

Wineparty / free

How a CANADIAN HISTORIAN supports WINEPARTY’s theses

The Canadian historian Rod Phillips has published a remarkable essay in the conservative British trade magazine “The World of Fine Wine”. His central thesis is as simple as it is uncomfortable: the international wine industry is not experiencing a temporary sales crisis. It is undergoing a cultural upheaval whose causes lie far beyond its own sphere of influence. And anyone who believes that a little wine marketing, friendlier tasting notes and a handful of tourist offerings can revive demand has not understood the problem.

Rod Phillips, himself no longer young, is not a representative of that public-health movement which sees alcohol primarily as a social evil. He is a historian. And he views the current development with the composure of a man who knows that cultures emerge, change and occasionally disappear. His diagnosis deserves attention. His almost exclusively pessimistic forecast, however, also deserves clear opposition.

Phillips describes a generation of young adults whose lifestyles differ considerably from those of their parents and grandparents. They drink less alcohol, spend less time with friends, go out to eat earlier, increasingly avoid traditional nightlife and regard professional performance, health and financial security as their primary goals in life. Shared drinking is thus losing the self-evident position it occupied in social life for decades.

Demographics also play a role. In Europe, the 20- to 34-year-old age group is now considerably smaller than the 40- to 54-year-old group. Even if younger people drank as much as their parents, consumption would have to decline in the long term. If they also drink less, the process accelerates. This is an argument against which even the most creative copywriter can do little. You can interest people in wine. But you cannot market consumers who were never born.

Phillips’ perspective on social isolation is particularly interesting. According to the American surveys he cites, 18- to 29-year-olds spent an average of thirteen hours a week with friends in 2010. By 2024, that figure was five. At the same time, the number of one-person households is rising. In Europe, roughly one in five households now consists of a single person; in the United States, one in three.

If wine is a drink of conviviality, this development must be a cause for concern. Anyone sitting alone at home staring at their smartphone needs neither a Blaufränkisch nor a Grüner Veltliner for that, but stuff that really knocks them out.
Phillips also describes the shift of social life into the earlier hours of the day. In London and New York, people are increasingly eating at five or six in the evening. Nightclubs are closing, while cafés remain open longer and young people attend alcohol-free dance events in the morning. The night, once the preferred territory of sociable alcohol consumption, is becoming less important.

These are observations that extend beyond the wine industry. They concern the hospitality sector, cities, leisure habits and, ultimately, the organisation of our social coexistence. Up to this point, I largely agree with Phillips.

But then his essay begins to derive a future from current behaviour that seems somewhat too definitive to me.
Phillips argues that younger generations have broken with the cultural ideas of their predecessors. They no longer perceive wine as a special cultural beverage, but simply as one alcoholic drink among others. The centuries-old narrative of wine’s special cultural status is losing its power to convince. There is initially little to object to here. Anyone who tells a twenty-year-old that they must drink wine because the ancient Greeks already drank wine should expect a certain bewilderment from their counterpart. Historical significance does not in itself create contemporary enthusiasm.

Phillips goes a step further, however. He considers the wine industry’s attempts to counter the decline through changed forms of communication, wine tourism and new occasions for consumption to be largely futile. The cultural and demographic changes are too profound Here things become problematic. For generations are not closed cultural units. They change over the course of their lives. They acquire different habits, different financial means and different interests. Someone who does not drink wine at twenty-five need not remain a teetotaller at forty-five.

The economic situation of younger people also deserves to be given a different weighting from that which Phillips accords it. He describes their concerns about employment, insecurity in the face of artificial intelligence, rising housing costs and the loss of financial leeway. From this, he infers greater restraint in alcohol consumption. But is this really a cultural turning away from wine? Or are we also seeing a generation that can no longer afford the way of life that seemed self-evident to their parents? That is a significant difference.

Anyone who has to spend a considerable proportion of their income on rent, energy and food will be able to afford a restaurant visit with a good bottle of wine less often. This does not, however, mean that they culturally reject such a restaurant visit. They simply cannot afford it. An economically imposed change in behaviour should not be hastily confused with a voluntary cultural decision.
---------------------------
And here Phillips touches, without explicitly examining it, on a broader social context with which WINEPARTY concerned itself only a few days ago. (Text by Manfred Klimek)

In his essay “Freedom, Prosperity and Wine”, Claude Auguste developed the thesis that the extraordinary rise of international wine culture since the 1970s was closely linked to the spread of liberal democracy, the economic rise of broad sections of the middle classes and globalisation. The opening of international markets, rising incomes and new social mobility enabled millions of people to gain access to a culture of indulgence that had previously been largely reserved for privileged circles. Now, however, the economic and political preconditions for this development are eroding. Liberal democracy is losing stability worldwide, the international economic order is being strained by protectionism and geopolitical conflicts, and the purchasing power of the middle classes is coming under pressure.

The crisis in winegrowing and the crisis of liberal democracy may therefore not be independent phenomena. They could be different symptoms of a more comprehensive social change.
And this is precisely where Phillips provides a remarkable addition to our essay. While Claude Auguste examined the political and economic-historical preconditions of the wine boom, Phillips describes the changes in the everyday lives of the people who once sustained that boom. The insecurity, the retreat from public life, the loss of shared leisure and the dwindling willingness to spend money on pleasure.

Both perspectives lead from different directions to a similar insight: the wine industry owes its extraordinary development to social preconditions whose continued existence is by no means guaranteed. Ensuring that they endure requires strategy.
----------------------
Phillips does not explicitly confirm our political thesis. But he provides weighty observations that support it. And he makes clear why the crisis in wine cannot be overcome solely through measures within the wine sector.
When the financial room for manoeuvre of the middle classes shrinks, international trade relations become uncertain and social confidence declines, this also affects wine. Its crisis is therefore not exclusively cultural in nature. It is equally a crisis of prosperity and social participation. It would have been interesting had Phillips explored this connection more fully.

His description of wine as by no means a unique cultural beverage also deserves a differentiated consideration. Naturally, there have been significant civilisations without wine. But this valid observation does not mean that wine’s cultural distinctiveness is merely a historical illusion. Wine is an agricultural product whose quality depends to an exceptional degree on origin, vintage, climate, soil, craft decisions and development over time. It brings nature and human labour together in a way that enables a particular form of engagement. One can talk about a wine in the same way as one talks about architecture, music or literature. One does not have to. But one can.

What the wine industry urgently needs to understand is this: it cannot secure its future by demanding the return of the consumers of the past. It must engage with the society in which its future customers will live. With their financial means, their lifestyles and their ideas about pleasure. It must become understandable again without becoming banal. It must be able to explain the value of its products without making their price the most important message. And it should not confuse the cultural significance of wine with a social obligation to consume it.
Rod Phillips has written an important text because he forces the wine industry to think beyond the boundaries of its own sector. And because his observations show how closely the future of wine is connected with social development. His error may be that he already regards the current cultural change as its historical outcome. I would not write off the future just yet.